As it Turns Out, ‘Return Of The Jedi’ is The Saddest Movie Ever Made
Nine years ago today, I remember it was a Saturday, I woke up to multiple missed calls from my father's phone number, which, you know, has no real possibility of being a good thing. When I called back, his longtime partner, Judy, answered. She was to the point: she had terrible news, my father had suffered a heart attack and he was gone.
No one is really prepared for news like this and there's no playbook for "what to do next." Though I do get the impression most people have tasks. I had no tasks. He did not want a funeral and I had no siblings (that I knew about).¹ There was no travel to book. There was really no one to call, though I did call my mom, even though they had been apart for many years. It was literally, "Here is the worst news I can possibly give you, now go about your day."
¹A few months later I would learn I have an older brother, which I wrote about here in this piece about meeting Taylor Swift a couple of weeks ago, which is a lot more than about meeting Taylor Swift:

That afternoon we wound up at a bar in our Manhattan neighborhood, Ethyl's, that plays movies on the televisions instead of sports. Return of the Jedi, of all things, was playing.
This was the first piece I wrote after returning to work. It's no longer online because Uproxx took down most of their archives. It’s a piece I think about a lot, with mixed feelings — even though, until today, I hadn't read it in nine years. There are parts that are a lot angrier than I remember. Rereading it now, I was obviously in a pretty bad place, but I do want to point out that I regret speaking ill of the Ewoks. This was not their fault. They are heroes.
I debated reposting this one. But I decided to go ahead and do it because sometimes things like this can have an effect on others, maybe. Related to this, a few months later Jason Sudeikis would send me this email that had a profound affect on me:

Anyway, here’s how that piece ran as it originally published (with some updated commentary), about what happened nine years ago today. Again, my apologies to the Ewoks.
As It Turns Out, ‘Return Of The Jedi’ Is The Saddest Movie Ever Made
“Check, please!”
This was the emphatic request of the poor fellow sitting to my right at a never-well-lit Upper East Side bar two Saturdays ago, five hours after I found out my father had died suddenly from a heart attack the night before.
After a few hours of doing nothing at our apartment (other than repeating to anyone who would listen that I didn’t know what I was supposed to do; no one really had an answer for me), my girlfriend convinced me to leave. And we settled on this particular bar because of the aforementioned lighting situation and that they play movies on their television screens rather than the sports that litter most of the taverns in this particular area of New York City.
Now, I need to preface this by saying that, in retrospect, I find this upcoming story pretty funny. At least, the optics are pretty funny to anyone who happened to be an outside observer. As it happened, the bar was playing Return of the Jedi, a movie I’ve seen far too many times to count. When we arrived, if I remember correctly, the movie was already to the part when C-3PO is explaining to the Ewoks everything that had happened in the prior movies up until they all arrived on Endor – as the Ewoks all sit there and get stoned, or whatever it is they do when they are not busy fucking up movies.²
²Hello from 2026. Yeah, I really don't know where this came from. I even own a Wicket hoodie.
Up until this point, I hadn’t had much of an emotional reaction to my dad dying. It didn’t seem real. He hadn’t been sick. I had just spoken to him two days before. In fact, I wasn’t entirely convinced that I wasn’t dreaming. Back when Inception came out, I read a lot of nonsense about how to have lucid dreams. One of the tests to decipher if an experience is dream or reality is to read a couple sentences of something, then turn away from it, then read it again. In a dream, the text will always be different. And this, surprisingly, actually does work when you’re dreaming. I tried this test on myself about ten times that morning and, no, I wasn’t dreaming.
Anyway, I wasn’t actively paying attention to Return of the Jedi, but I happened to glance up right when Luke Skywalker was trying to help Darth Vader escape the about-to-explode second Death Star. Also at this moment, The Byrds’ version of “Turn! Turn! Turn!” started playing on the bar’s speaker system. It was the perfect storm of nostalgic sorrow. So when Vader tells Luke that he for once wants to see Luke with his own eyes, I lost it. I was actively sobbing at the bar while watching Return of the Jedi. This was the first time of many times I would cry about my dad over the upcoming two weeks.
At this point, I just imagine the camera panning out to reveal a stranger sitting next to me, uncomfortably – wondering why this person next to him thought Return of the Jedi was just so sad. I now imagine this person telling his friends about the guy sitting next to him at a bar on a drizzly Saturday afternoon who, I’m sure, thinks I had never seen Return of the Jedi and just thought it was the saddest thing. “Wait, this is how it all ends! Why? Why?!?! [starts crying].”
This is a free post for "free tier" subscribers. But The Hard Pass only exists because of paying subscribers. If you become a paying subscriber to The Hard Pass, it will be greatly appreciated.

